Planting Science - Projects: Plants vs AP Bio
You are here: Home / Groups / CAMS Piatt POS Fall 2023 / Projects / Plants vs AP Bio

Plants vs AP Bio

Project by group camspiattposfall2023


Info

Explore We know that plants go through processes called photosynthesis and cellular respiration. In class, we have discovered how plants and trees get their mass, what happens in the processes plants go through, why they go through these processes, and more.
Research Question Does the lack of pigment affect the rate of photosynthesis? We developed the question by noticing the white bit of a plant, which we believed was a lack of pigment, and wondered if the lack of pigments in the bits leaves changed the rate how the plant photosynthesizes.
Predictions The lack of pigment(s) in the plants could either change the rate of photosynthesis in the plant. If they change the rate, it could either slow the rate down or speed it up. We are comparing how fast the plants with lack of pigment go through photosynthesis when placed under a light. We believe...
Experimental Design To test what pigments are in the leaves, we decided to do a chromatography experiment. To do this, we collected a quarter, chromatography paper, our plants, and some chromatography solvent. We took the plant and placed it on the paper, and rolled the quarter on it so the pigment will transfer...
Conclusion To conclude our experiment, we can make the claim that plant leaves without pigment experience photosynthesis at a lower rate than plant leaves with pigments. Plant leaves use chloroplasts to carry out the processes of photosynthesis, and chloroplasts also give plants their green color, so the...
About this Project The students showed great interest in developing the experiment, were curious about the results, asked good questions about factors taht can influence on the experiments, and were always looking for ways to get better and improve their experiment. -- Gabriela Hernandes Villani,...

Updates

Get to know your team’s scientist mentor, who will encourage and guide you through the scientific process of discovery. The more you share your ideas and research info, the more your mentor can help. You may also hear from a scientist mentor liaison who will be helping all the teams in your class.
Gabriela H. Villani
said

Ok! Let me know if you need any help doing the poster. 

Gabriela

Aiden
said

Hi Gabriela!

In our final experiment, we concluded that the lack of pigment caused the rate of photosynthesis to be much lower or almost non-existent. We prepared 4 cups, each with 4 drops of the soap-water mixture, and an even amount of baking soda. We cut out 10 leaves from the red nerve cell plant and 10 bits of the leaves that lacked pigment in each cup. We placed them under the light for 20 minutes, just like we did with our previous leaf disk experiment. After the 20 minutes, only the leaves from the red nerve cell plant had floated. When we came back the next day, some of the leaves from the other plant had floated, but we discovered this is due to the fact there was a little bit of pigment on the edge of the leaves. 

We as a team appreciate the time you took to respond to us and thank you for answering all of our questions! We really enjoyed this experience and learned a lot from it. 

    Gabriela H. Villani
    said

    Hi Team!

    Congrats on finishing the project! It is great when we can prove our hypothesis, isn't it? 
    Are you doing some kind of presentation about the project in class?

    Thank you for being very participative students! It is been great work with you all!

    Gabriela 

    Addacie
    said

    Hi Gabriela!

    I do not believe we arre doing any final project in class,, but if we do there may be a poster. It was wonderful communicating with you, and it was great to work with you. 

    Addacie

Aiden
uploaded IMG_6285.jpg and 4 more files in project files
Aiden
updated the project info
Addacie
said

When we were doing the chromotograpghy experiment to test what pigments were in the leaves, we could not isolate the other pigments in the red nerve cell plant. However, we noticed the white parts on our curly spider plant was a lack of pigment, so we decided to change our research question. Instead of doing how different pigments affect the rate of photosynthesis, we switched our research question to how does the lack of pigment affect the rate of photosynthesis. While this isn't what we wanted to do orignially, we are able to take the data we got from the chromotograpghy and develop a new research question. 

    Gabriela H. Villani
    said

    Hi Team!

    Good alternative! I am happy to see that you were able to rethink and adapt the research question to a new scenario. Congratulations!! This is very common in science! Many times we need to adapt and redesign our experiments to what we really have (for real) in the moment. 

Addacie
said

While I was preparing to clean up our previous, I noticed one of my cups with leaves had turned clear almost transluscent. I have had these cups sitting on the counter since our last documentation and I noticed the leaves were different. Why is this?

    Gabriela H. Villani
    said

    Hi Addacie! You mean the leaves were almost translucent or the liquid (then, are you talking about the red phenol?)

    Addacie
    said

    Hi! The leaves were transluscent. We had the leaves in a cup of water with baking soda and 4 drops of soap. 

    Gabriela H. Villani
    said

    Leaves becoming translucent after being left in water for some time is likely due to a process called osmosis. Osmosis is the movement of water across a semipermeable membrane, such as the cell membrane of plant cells.

    When you place leaves in water, water molecules move from an area of lower solute concentration (in this case, the water in the cup) to an area of higher solute concentration (inside the plant cells). Plant cells contain various solutes, including salts, sugars, and other dissolved substances. As water enters the plant cells through osmosis, it causes the cells to swell and become turgid.

    The increased water content in the plant cells can cause the cells to expand, making the leaves appear translucent. This is because the cell walls are flexible, and the water fills the intercellular spaces. Additionally, the increased water content may cause the chloroplasts within the cells to spread out, making the green color of the chlorophyll less concentrated and contributing to the translucent appearance.

Addacie
updated the project info
Addacie
said

Hi Gabriela!

Today we began discussing our final experiment. We took the time to develop a few research questions and decided on one question. 

1. Do plants with different pigments affect the rate of photosynthesis? 

The two plants we picked out to conduct this experiment are the red nerve cell plant and the curly spider plant. To determine an answer for our research question, we have two processes we plan on going through.

First, we plan on identifying what kinds of pigments are in the different parts of the plants. To do this, we are going to use a chromoatography solvent, chromotography paper, and chambers. We also want to test different areas on the plants. We plan on taking out different bits of the plants that have different colors on each plant to see. 

After we identify what pigment(s) are in the plants, we plan on conducting the leaf disk experiment with these plants. We will set it up the same way we set up our last leaf disk experiment. Depending on how many leaves we can get from our plants, we want to put 5-10 leaf disks in each cup with water and the water/soap solution. We also plan on putting an equal amount of baking soda in ecah cup as well. We will place it under the same light we did before and track the rate at which each cups photosynthesize.

Do you have any suggestions for how we should conduct these experiments? If certain bits of the plant that we use have a lack of pigment, could that affect how the plant photosynthesize? 

Thanks! 

    Gabriela H. Villani
    said

    Hi Team!! 

    That's super exciting you are developing your own experiment!! Now, you are scientists too :)

    I loved your research question! 

    Congrats on the organized plan!

    I would say to:

    *get 10 leaf discs from each plant (more material will reduce the possibility of a not accurate result due to specific characteristics of that leaf area that is not good).

    *get discs radonmly from different leaves (a more randominized sample collection will help with a more homogeneous results, not bias by 1 leaf that might have unique characterists that are influencing the results).

    *a lack of pigment will influence on the results as we already know photosynthesis is driven by pigments. So, do not take discs from areas with no pigments. Unless you wanna test the research question that photosysnthesis is driven by pigments. 

    Excited to see your results!! Post pictures too, please, I love them!

    Gabriela

Addacie
updated the project info
Addacie
uploaded IMG_0771.HEIC in project files
Addacie
updated the project info
Gabriela H. Villani
uploaded IMG_5731.png in project files
Gabriela H. Villani
said

Hello Aiden, Addacie, and Bailey! 
 

That's right! Green Light is not good for photosynthesis because this light is not absorbed. This happens because the chloroplasts are green, thus the green light is reflected.

If we are talking about regular bulbs, the sunlight is more effective because the sun emits a continuous wavelength with more of the beneficial wavelengths for photosynthesis. I'm gonna post a graph about it next, so you can check it. 

Let me know if you have more questions, 

Gabriela 

 

Gabriela H. Villani
said

Hello Aiden, Addacie, and Bailey! 

Great to see your progress!! :) 

Thanks for the detailed description, this is very important when we are writing about an experiment. 

That's right, adding COin the phenol red solution makes the pH decrease and changes its color to yellow. That's why you saw the color change in the cups that you blew with the straw and in the ones in the dark (where respiration is happening, which consumes O2 and releases CO2). 

On the other hand, in the cups where photosynthesis is happening, COis being consumed, which increases the pH and changes the color back to pink/red.

The fog you noticed at the top of the tubes is water vapor condensation, that's right. 

That's amazing to see how light influences plants and evidence that photosynthesis is occurring, right?

There are many things that can influence photosynthesis, such as chlorophyll content, stomata conductance, leaf water content, and light. Photosynthesis occurs better in blue and red light spectrum, because chlorophyll absorbs light in the red wavelength and the carotenoids (other kind of pigment) absorbs blue light and pass the energy to choropphyl.  

That is why you can find some special lights with red and blue lights in gardening stores. Thus, when you use these lights, you will increase the photossynthesis rates and make the plant grows faster. 

Can you think of what light is not good for photossynthesis?
Hint: Remember the color definition we learn in physics class. 

See you,

Gabriela

    Aiden
    said

    Hello Gabriela,

    Thank you for responding and commenting on our progress. We appreciate you taking time to read over our experiment and respond back with comments and questions.

    In response to your question, is green light not good for photosynthesis? Since chloroplasts appear green they reflect green light, they would not be able to absorb green light in order to pass on energy. 

    Also, does sunlight provide a better energy source for photosynthesis than a regular, artificial lightbulb? If the answer is yes, how come?

    Thanks,

    Aiden

Addacie
said

After finishing our experiments, we have determined that light effects photosynthesis. Light increases the rate that photosynthesis occurs. In the second leaf disk experiment we did, we put two cups in a box in a dark corner and two cups under a light. Each cup had the same amount of baking soda and, 4 drops of a soap and water mixture, and the same amount of leaves. For this experiment, we ended up putting 10 leaves in each cup. After twenty minutes, all of the leaves in the cups under the light had floated. None of the leaves in the dark cups had floated. This is how we determined that light effects the rate of photosynthesis. After conducting this part of our experiment, we decided to switch the cups and leave them overnight. 10/20 of the leaves placed under the light floated and all of the leaves in the dark had no change. This is how we determined that the prescense of light is needed for plantsto photosynthesize. 

In our second exeperiment involving the elodea plants, we also discovered that photosynthesis was occuring under the light. Elodea in the light with CO2 intially turned from yellow to pink. The CO2 was moving into the Elodea, being used for photosynthesis. The elodea in the dark with CO2 started yellow and ended the same color. The CO2 was not used up. However, after completing this lab we discovered that due to unclear directions we had set up the elodea experiment incorrectly. We had a cup of phenyl red and blew into it before hand to turn it yellow before adding it to our tubes instead of adding the phenyl red without breathing into it to see how it changes. However, based on the knowledge we have regarding the experiment we conducted, we can determine what would happen if we did it correctly. Elodea in the dark wthout CO2 would start as pink/red and would turn yellow after 24 hours. The elodea is making CO2. CO2 increased in the test tube turning yellow.

What would you do different in these experiments to get better results? Would a different kind of light source change the rate of photosynthesis. 

Addacie
uploaded IMG_0527.HEIC and 4 more files in project files
Aiden
said

Update from our recent lab. We are currently investigating the role light has on plants. The tubes on the left were left in the light for 24 hours, and the tubes on the right were left in the dark for 24 hours. One tube in each batch contained an elodea plants, and all tubes contained a phenol red solution that we added CO2 to through straws. Based on the color of the solutions, I predict that the plant in the phenol red solution under light went through photosynthesis. The original phenol red solution was a pink color, but when we breathed into the cups through straws to introduce CO2, the solution turned yellow. The plant consumed the CO2 that was in the solution to go through photosynthesis, effectively removing CO2 from the phenol red and changing it back to its original pink color. The top of the tubes are foggy, which is probably O2 gas emitted from the photosynthesis reaction. The tube on the far left had a few leaves in the tube still so that is probably why there is some gas. The tubes in the dark has no visible changes and there is no visible gas in the tubes.

 

Edit: Looking back on the photos, I realize that the condensation in the tubes on the right is most likely water vapor as a byproduct of photosynthesis. Is this accurate?

Aiden
uploaded elodea.jpg in project files
Gabriela H. Villani
said

Hi Aiden and Bailey!

You are right! The gas that is being formed is oxygen due to the photosynthesis that is going on.

Talking about the errors you mentioned:

"Some errors we noticed in the lab was that right away in one of the cups 4 of the leaves floated when added to the cup. They had sunk in the syringe so we weren't entirely sure where we went wrong when putting them into the cup."

Maybe some air got into it while transferring from the syringe to the cup. Try to open the syringe inside the water in the cups. I think you can remove the plunger and very quickly put your finger to close it, and place it inside the water before release it to free the leaves directly inside the water. Makes sense? 


"We also didn't get all the leaves to float in the ones we believe should have. "

Maybe those leaves parts were not good, there are many things that can affect photopsynthesis (besides the environment factor), like chlorophyll content. 

Let me know how it goes on Thursday!

Gabriela

Clarissa Moore
joined the project
PlantingScience Staff
joined the project
Aiden
said

Hello. My name is Aiden and I am a student in AP Bio. I am very interested in the field of biology and I plan to continue with biology throughout college. I noticed you like hiking and traveling, so what is your favorite place to travel to or what is a place that you really want to travel to?

Addacie
said

Hi Gabriela! To answer your question about the climate, over the past few years of my life I have noticed how the climate has been changing. I, however, am not entirely sure why. I do not have a favorite trip yet, but I will be traveling to Canada soon to skydive, so I believe that will be my favorite trip soon. This lab branched off the question how does CO2 affect photosynthesis. In our leaf disk experiement, we discovered that carbon dioxide is necessary for photosynthesis. While there were some errors in our lab, we got results that were accurate enough to determine this. Some evidence we have includes the fact that the baking soda cup eventually developed bubbles around the leaves and a couple in the breath cup as well. We also noticed that none of the leaves floated in the water cup but almost all the leaves floated in the other two cups. We discovered a gas was produced, but do not have enough evidence to confirm what is is. Do you have any suggestions for creating less errors in this lab if we do another trial? 

    Gabriela H. Villani
    said

    Hi Addacie! I'm gonna break up your questions/comments to make it easier to answer them:

    1. "over the past few years of my life, I have noticed how the climate has been changing. I, however, am not entirely sure why. "

    Here is a nice short video that explains why climate change is happening now due to human activities:  https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ffjIyms1BX4&ab_channel=BeSmart

    If you have free time on a weekend with some popcorn, here is a nice documentary about it: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pEt6-jA2UE4&ab_channel=DWDocumentary

    2. "I will be traveling to Canada soon to skydive, so I believe that will be my favorite trip soon."

    Skydive is on my bucket list! I have never done it, but it looks like a unique experience, good luck!! 

     

    3. "We also noticed that none of the leaves floated in the water cup but almost all the leaves floated in the other two cups. We discovered a gas was produced, but do not have enough evidence to confirm what is is. "

    Let's think...

    In both the "breath cup" and "baking soda cup" you are adding CO2, right? Which is the gas necessary for photosynthesis to occur. So, photosynthesis is occurring in these cups and as a result, you can see the bubbles and the discs floating. 

     Which gas is formed in photosynthesis? This is the gas you saw forming around the leaf discs in these two cups.

    Now, can you understand why in these 2 cups there is photosynthesis going on and why you see the leaf discs floating? Did you understand why they are floating?

    On the "water cup," there is pretty much just H20 molecules, so there is not enough CO2 source to trigger photosynthesis in the leaf discs. Thus, they do not float. 

    Can you describe what kind of errors are you talking about?

    See you,

    Gabriela 

     

     

    Addacie
    said

    Hi!

    While we didn't have much evidence of the gas, we did conspire that the gas might be oxygen since we know the products of photosynthesis is glucose and oxygen. We can see the leaves floating in these cups since there is more CO2 in the breath cup and baking soda cup compared to the water cup. 

    Some errors we noticed in the lab was that right away in one of the cups 4 of the leaves floated when added to the cup. They had sunk in the syringe so we weren't entirely sure where we went wrong when putting them into the cup. We also didn't get all the leaves to float in the ones we believe should have. We will be redoing the experiment on Thursday this week so we'll make sure to update you on how it goes!

    Thanks for responding and we look forward to updating you on Thursday! 

Aiden
updated the project info
Addacie
said

Hi! My name is Addacie and I am a student in AP Biology. I am excited to work with you on this project. I was wondering what made you get into this field of study? 

    Gabriela H. Villani
    said

    Hi Addacie! I have been always aware of deforestation news and its bad consequences for our planet and for us. Then, 3 years ago I got a job at a reforestation company. As I really enjoyed the job, I thought about back to Graduate school in an area focused on forestry and possible Climate Change consequences as we still little know about how forests (especially tropical forests, which I work with) will react to rising temperatures. In a nutshell, that's how I am in this Plant Biology Master's program now :)

Addacie
uploaded IMG_0294.HEIC and 4 more files in project files
Gabriela H. Villani
said

Hello Team!

I’m Gabriela, your liaison. I’m an Environmental and Sanitary Engineer from São Paulo, Brazil. Also, I am a Master’s student in Plant Biology at Oklahoma State University.

My role as liaison is to support you and check in to be sure everything goes well with your group. Also, I may step in to respond to the students if the mentor hasn’t responded to their questions in 2-3 days. Whenever I do so, it doesn't stop the mentor from continuing to communicate with the group. 
My research is related to ecology and climate change. Have you noticed how climate has been changing through the last decades? Do you know why and how this is happening? 
I’ve been interested in plants since my childhood. I remember my mom making tea with medicinal herbs and I was amazed about how the plants can help us. Do you usually use medicinal herbs too? If so, which ones? My favorite ones are lavender and rosemary!
In my free time, I like hiking and traveling to know new places. What is your favorite trip so far? Also, I play flute and like to learn new music. What about you, what do you like to do in your free time?

Looking forward to meeting you all!

Gabriela

Bailey
said

Hello! My name is Bailey and I am a student in AP Bio. I do not know a lot about plants, but I am excited to learn and very open to the idea. I was wondering what got you interested in bumblebee diversity?

Bailey
joined the project
Addacie
joined the project
Aiden
joined the project
Michele Piatt
joined the project
Gabriela H. Villani
joined the project
PlantingScience Staff
said

Welcome to your PlantingScience project page!

Welcome to this community of plant researchers. As your team plans and conducts your own research project, you will be mentored by a scientist. The mentor's role is to encourage and guide you through the process of scientific discovery. The more you share your ideas and research information online, the more your mentor can help. You can also find out more about your mentor. What is their research about? Why did they go into science? What do they like to do when they are not working?

You may also hear from this classroom’s assigned scientist liaison. Liaisons work with several mentors and help make sure the conversations are going strong. They may also offer some extra advice or encouragement.

Two resources can help you get started:

Best wishes as you start this scientific journey. We are all pleased to share this experience with you. Have fun!

To set up your project page:

  • Upload a photo or avatar for your team.
  • Introduce yourselves to your scientist mentor and get the conversation started!
  • PLEASE ONLY CLICK "Share with team" ONCE. Sometimes the page takes a little while to refresh, so please be patient!

In order to protect student privacy, please DO NOT share:

  • last names
  • social media handles
  • links to Google/Sharepoint documents, spreadsheets, or images

We will remove these items as we find them in posts.

LogoWithTags.png

f_logo_RGB-Black_72.png 2021_Twitter_logo_-_black.png icons8-mail-30.png

ABOUT THE PROGRAM

GET INVOLVED AS A TEACHER  *   GET INVOLVED AS A SCIENTIST MENTOR

SUPPORT US!   *   TERMS OF USE

NSF_Logo.jpg This material is based upon work supported by the National Science Foundation under Grant #2010556 and #1502892. Any opinions, findings, and conclusions or recommendations expressed in this material are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the views of the National Science Foundation.

Copyright © 2022 PlantingScience -- Powered by HUBzero®, a Purdue project