Planting Science - Projects: Tree-m Team <3
You are here: Home / Groups / CAMS Davis Spring 2021 / Projects / Tree-m Team <3

Tree-m Team <3

Project by group camsdavisspring2021

Info

Explore Having observed six trees of different species, sizes, and shapes, we recorded our findings and learned more about trees in general. For example, we found a 13-foot apple tree that has a reddish color near the base of the trunk, a thin-trunk malunggay tree that’s just starting to grow new leaves,...
Research Question How does the health of a tree affect how a cutting (leaves and a branch) dies? We came up with this question after reminiscing about our childhood experiences with snapping leaves and branches only to see them rot and die. This question fits what we know about trees because without a direct line...
Predictions We predict that the leaves/branches from the healthiest tree will die the least or the slowest because they have enough nutrients and necessities stored to last a while; the leaves/branches from the least healthy tree will die the fastest and in the worst way because they don't have as much...
Experimental Design Our plan is to cut off a branch with some leaves on it from each of five trees and record how fast and in what way the leaves die once separated from the tree (see steps in Files for details). The variables we are testing are the health of the leaves (determined by color, size, shape, and...
Conclusion From this experiment, we can conclude that cuttings from healthier trees will develop leaf rot and die slightly faster than those from less healthy trees. This is likely because healthier leaves contain more water, which can contribute to the growth of leaf rot (we researched that moisture is...
About this Project

Updates

Get to know your team’s scientist mentor, who will encourage and guide you through the scientific process of discovery. The more you share your ideas and research info, the more your mentor can help. You may also hear from a scientist mentor liaison who will be helping all the teams in your class.
PlantingScience Staff
said

Looks like you are in the final stages of your projects.

It’s great to see that teams from your school are wrapping up and posting conclusions. Enjoy the final stages of your project, and feel free to post any final comments or questions you have for your mentors.

You have until Tuesday, April 25, 2021, for final posts to be added, so please be sure to thank your fellow teammates soon!

Rebekah S. Marsh
said

Hello Tree-m Team~
It was a pleasure to work with all of you – Jemimah, Ava, Summer, Camille and Samanta!  Though the results were not what were expected, that is research (the continual search for new information) and science.  You did gain information from the experiments and are walking away with an experience that showed you the fun aspect of science.

Wishing you all the best.

Dr. Marsh

Jemimah
said

Hello Dr. Marsh

It was a pleasure working with you, and we just want to let you know how our experiment went. So, unfortunately, our results didn't match our hypothesis. Basically, our healthiest tree (Siggy) had its leaves rot the fastest while our unhealthiest tree's (Barnaby) leaves rotted the slowest. Perhaps that because of the species of tree we worked on or that's just how leaf rot works. It was definitely an interesting final result. So perhaps the opposite of our hypothesis is true.

Just a reminder that this was our hypothesis: "The leaves/branches from the healthiest tree will die the least or the slowest because they have enough nutrients and necessities stored to last a while. The leaves/branches from the least healthy tree will die the fastest and in the worst way because they don't have as much support left in them once cut off from the tree."

Also, we wanted to let you know that we did a group presentation about our project and we believe that it went well. Our teacher liked our slides and the information we presented.

Again, thank you for being our mentor, we really enjoyed doing this project. Goodbye! <3

- Treem Team <3

Ava
updated the project info
Summer
said

Hi, Dr. Marsh,

Thanks so much for your work and contributions to this project! It was great to have you on the Treem Team and you gave some really invaluable feedback. Thank you so much!

Best wishes

-Summer, Treem Team <3

Camille
said

Hi Dr. Marsh,

Just wanted to say thank you for being our mentor and giving us great advice and feedback throughout this project. We had fun doing this experiment and we're sad that this is coming to an end. It was a pleasure working with you!

-Tree-m Team <3

Samanta
said

Hello Dr.Marsh!

Today is the last day for our experiment and we just finished presenting! :)

We all enjoyed working with you, and valued your help and input throughout our experiment. It was wonderful working with you, and I wish you the best!

- Tree-m Tream <3

Ava
said

Hello again, Dr. Marsh,

Thank you for mentoring us and helping us with our experiment! It's been great being a part of Tree-m Team and having fun on this project! Our conclusion should be updated and Jemimah can go into more detail about the results.

Have a great weekend and again, thank you!

- Ava, Tree-m Team <3

Summer
said

Hi Dr. Marsh,

We are continuing to collect data in the same format as last time. Over half of our branches have developed what we think is a type of leaf rot, but it doesn’t seem to be developing in just the healthiest or least healthy branches (we saw it first in Siggy and now Willow and Dimitri have it). We can attach some pictures if you would like to take a look at it! Also, our school is going on Spring Break starting today, so we won’t be working too hard on the project.

~Tree-m Team <3

Summer
said

Hello Dr. Marsh, Tree-m Team here!

We have started collecting data on our cut branches. Since our branches/twigs were cut on the 16th around 1:00pm, that’s what we consider the start time for our experiment and we are collecting data and making observations daily at that time. We record the health of the leaves using the healthometer and the amount of leaves left of the branch; we also take notes and pictures on how the branches are looking/if they are drying out/any other interesting qualitative data we find. In short, the healthiest of our trees (Siggy’s) leaves aren’t losing their green color but they are drying up and crinkling --  no leaves have fallen off yet but the leaf health has dropped from an initial 9.5 to an 8.5 on the healthometer. The branch from the second healthiest tree (Hazel’s) leaves are turning more yellow but once again none have fallen all the way off though a couple of the stems connecting leaves to the branch are looking quite weak (healthometer 9 to 8). The third healthiest (Willow’s) branch is dehydrating, also turning more yellow, and starting to lose the small flowers that bloomed on it (healthometer 8 to 6.5). Our fourth healthiest (Dimitri’s) branch has significantly lightened in color and the places on the leaves that we brown before have dried completely and fallen off (healthometer 7 to 5.5). Our least healthy tree (Barnaby’s) sample is shedding its bark in places and the leaves are becoming more yellow, especially on the back of leaves where there is almost no green now, and the brown places have broken off (healthometer 6 to 5). If you would like to see more pictures or data we have it available!

P.S. We named our trees for convenience and there are initial pictures for each tree in files!

 

~Tree-m Team <3

    Rebekah S. Marsh
    said

    Thank you for the update Summer and Tree-m Team!

    All the observations you have mentioned sound good, great job.  I did look at the photos and they are good as well.  I had a few suggestions come to mind.  If you can get a close up of the leaves on the tree – that way you can have a standard of health to go by for each tree.  I could see the full tree but not a leaf or a few leaves to discern it was healthy.  Does that make sense.   Another idea/thought after reviewing your observations was check around the trees and take observations and photos something in ground or around the tree could affect how the water is able to access/”drink”.  That information could be used in conclusions to support what you saw/observe.  Just an idea that is all.

    It does look good; cannot wait for more data!  Have a great weekend.

    P.S. I did enjoy the names of the trees.

    Dr. Marsh

Ava
uploaded Our Trees.pdf in project files
Rebekah S. Marsh
said

Hello Tree-m

It looks good.  One suggestion when labeling would be to use colored string; that can be tied off/secure. Or make tags tied to string tie to the twig and tree. That may help organize cuttings and reduce potential errors in data collection (and/or loss of tags due to nature)..

Hope this helps.

Dr. Marsh

Ava
said

Hi, Dr. Marsh! We've officially made our Experimental Design! The brief version is above in the Experimental Design box, and we've uploaded our detailed steps and Health-O-Meter (to quantify the health of trees and leaves) in Files. Does everything look good? Should we include anything else?

This might be our last update for this week, so have a nice weekend!

~Tree-m Team <3

Ava
uploaded Experimental Design Steps and Health-O-Meter.pdf in project files
Ava
updated the project info
Ava
said

Happy Tuesday, Dr. Marsh! Alright, we have an update. We tweaked our research question a bit so we have a solid independent variable, which is the health of the tree. So to be clear, we are going to take a cutting each from five trees of the same species but varying health and comparing how they rot from each tree. We also made some predictions and updated that section with how we hypothesize our results will be.

We can't wait to get started!

~ Tree-m team <3

Ava
updated the project info
Ava
said

Good afternoon, Dr. Marsh. Thank you for your advice! Our tentative research question is now our definite research question. We will be cutting the branches all the way off with clippers (or something) and comparing how the leaves on the branch and the leaves on the tree look. We are going to make some scales to quantify some of our variables (we're very good at making scales, we had so much fun last time).

Have a great weekend!

~ Tree-m Team <3

    Rebekah S. Marsh
    said

    Sounds like a plan Tree-m Team. 

    I am excited to see the experiments and results.

    Have a good weekend.

    Dr. Marsh

Ava
updated the project info
Ava
said

Happy Thursday! We've been doing some exploring to think about what we want to experiment with, and we came up with a few research questions. Right now, our top pick is "How does snapping or breaking a branch (or leaf, we're undecided) affect the health of that branch (or leaf)?" Finding a branch or twig or stem that has a cluster of leaves growing, or just a leaf with a stem by itself, we would break it just enough to make a dent but leave it on the tree. Theoretically, the leaves or the branch itself would rot and die due to the cut off of its necessities. We would measure how long it took for the leaves to completely die, and things like the color and size of the leaves. We have a lot of options with this question, like what specifically we would experiment on and what it would affect.

So, how does our tentative question sound? Is there anything else would should take into consideration, or does it sound like it is not feasible?

Thank you!

~ Tree-m Team <3

    Rebekah S. Marsh
    said

    Hello Team;)

    The tentative question is good.  I had a few thoughts/things to consider – I think rather than breaking what about cutting with clippers.  That type of “break” occurs in a consistent way (it follows the shape of the clipper blades versus breaking which can be and usually is not consistent).  You could compare and contrast the impact of those on the tree and/leaf.  I know there are time constraints, so one or the other may be the goal.

    I think using a branch with many leaves may be the better option to perform the experiment; that way the branch is the main source versus different branches on the tree and the tree is the source.

    Those are my suggestions; I hope they help.
    Have good weekend Tree-m Team!

    Dr. Marsh

Ava
said

Hi Dr. Marsh! I just wanted to clarify some of the things you mentioned about what we wrote for the Explore. We actually did use multiple apps to try to find out what the anonymous tree was; the closest result we got was Laurus nobilis, but we didn't want to present false information because like we said, we're not entirely sure. By smaller trees, we meant those with thin trucks and not many leaves; for example, the yucca tree we mentioned has a very think trunk and is relatively small in comparison to a wild yucca or any other full-grown tree (which I believe is due to the fact that it is growing in a small pot). Green leaves on any of our trees would likely suggest that the tree is performing photosynthesis, but we decided that crispy, yellowed edges of leaves means it gets too much Sun.

As for the next stage of our project, we actually have no idea what we're doing yet. Of course, you'll be the first to know :)

Have a great weekend!

~ Tree-m Team <3

    Rebekah S. Marsh
    said

    Hello Ava and Tree-m Team

    Thanks for the additional information.  I would agree with you – about the unknown tree.  You did your best researching it and found the best educated guess without having confirmation – which is as good as you can get. 

    I agree about the smaller tree in a pot – the pot more than likely was affecting the growth of the tree.

    Also, the leaves which had yellow edges and were crispy were performing little to no photosynthesis.

    Cannot wait to hear from you on the next stages.

    Have a great week.

    Dr. Marsh

Ava
updated the project info
Summer
said

Hello Dr. Marsh, we’re here with our weekly update! We’ve started doing initial research on trees around our houses and we recorded information about them such as tree diameter, observation on the tree’s health (we noted things like peeling bark, broken or dry leaves, exposed roots, etc.), and used an online analysis tool to obtain estimates for tree benefits (such as CO2 absorbed or stormwater intercepted). More information about the trees we observed is located under the Explore tab under Info!

    Rebekah S. Marsh
    said

    Summer and Tree-m Team~
    I read through the ‘Explore’ information.  There are some diverse trees in your area.  The one leafy tree that you were not too sure of; can you take pictures of it (base of trunk, trunk, branches and leaves) and possibly get a leaf to research what type of tree it is?  If you can, I would encourage it – maybe it is native to California?  Or a unique tree species.

    The smaller trees  - why are they smaller?  Are they smaller because that is the nature of that tree species or is it a juvenile tree? If their leaves are green do you think that they are performing photosynthesis? 

    Great information – what is the next stage in the research?

    Have a great Friday and weekend.
    Dr. Marsh

Summer
updated the project info
Samanta
said

Hello, my name is Samanta, and I'm a speaker for the group! I like playing online multiplayer games and drawing, and hope we have a good time with this project! 

    Rebekah S. Marsh
    said

    Samanta~

    It is nice to meet you.  I have enjoyed a few online backgammon games (thank you my grandfather – he taught me) and UNO;)  Do you have a favorite subject/topic you like drawing?

    I am excited to work with you and the team.

    Dr. Marsh

LogoWithTags.png

f_logo_RGB-Black_72.png 2021_Twitter_logo_-_black.png icons8-mail-30.png

ABOUT THE PROGRAM

GET INVOLVED AS A TEACHER  *   GET INVOLVED AS A SCIENTIST MENTOR

SUPPORT US!   *   TERMS OF USE

NSF_Logo.jpg This material is based upon work supported by the National Science Foundation under Grant #2010556 and #1502892. Any opinions, findings, and conclusions or recommendations expressed in this material are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the views of the National Science Foundation.

Copyright © 2022 PlantingScience -- Powered by HUBzero®, a Purdue project